From ba2b3bf3172e7c999f79eea2986522c12be9630e Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Chris Troutner Date: Thu, 27 Aug 2026 09:59:49 -0700 Subject: [PATCH] Review and harden set-avatar-url profile-text refactor Merge refactorer set-avatar-url work: shared MemoProfileTextAction base with a profileTextConfig factory so MemoSetName/MemoSetBio/MemoSetAvatarUrl become thin config declarations, plus avatar URL byte-limit, round-trip, and byte budget property tests. No hardening fix required; language mutation reports no survivors and soft Gherkin acceptance mutation survivors are documented equivalents. Record the durable review report. By architect. --- docs/reviews/set-avatar-url-summary.md | 80 +++++++++++++++++++ psf-memo-client/specs/set-avatar-url.feature | 4 + psf-memo-client/specs/set-bio.feature | 2 +- psf-memo-client/specs/set-name.feature | 2 +- .../src/services/memo-profile-text-action.js | 4 + .../src/services/memo-set-avatar-url.js | 2 +- psf-memo-client/src/services/memo-set-bio.js | 2 +- psf-memo-client/src/services/memo-set-name.js | 2 +- 8 files changed, 93 insertions(+), 5 deletions(-) create mode 100644 docs/reviews/set-avatar-url-summary.md diff --git a/docs/reviews/set-avatar-url-summary.md b/docs/reviews/set-avatar-url-summary.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a655f1d --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/reviews/set-avatar-url-summary.md @@ -0,0 +1,80 @@ +# Review summary: set-avatar-url + +**Architect review of the refactorer handoff for task `set-avatar-url`.** + +## Commits reviewed +- `991053a` (specifier): Spec Set Avatar URL feature. +- `7bee85a` (coder): Implement Set Avatar URL client feature — `memo-set-avatar-url.js`, + `set-avatar-url-page.js`, account/set-avatar-url React components, acceptance handlers, + and unit tests. +- `131d31e` (refactorer): Merge coder set-avatar-url implementation. +- `58e21ff01a` (refactorer): Deduplicate Memo profile-text actions and add set-avatar-url + property tests — extracted a shared `MemoProfileTextAction` base with a `profileTextConfig` + factory so `MemoSetName`, `MemoSetBio`, and `MemoSetAvatarUrl` each become a thin data + declaration, removing the duplicated config and broadcast method; added property tests + covering the avatar URL byte limit, round trips, and byte budget conservation. + +Merged with the prior chain commits (`2eb86e2` specifier backlog update, `e321c7f` revert of +an unrelated specifier-model change in `swarmforge.conf`). + +## Architectural findings and fixes applied +The refactorer's structure is sound. `MemoSetName`/`MemoSetBio`/`MemoSetAvatarUrl` are now +thin config-driven subclasses of the shared `MemoProfileTextAction` base, which supplies the +config factory and the broadcast-method binding; the three actions differ only in their +protocol prefix, byte limit, error codes, and profile-store method. UI/Core separation, +dependency direction, and information hiding all hold: the wallet and profiles store are +injected, keeping the module free of network/UI concerns behind small adapter boundaries. +The client remains the only component touched; no `psf-memo-db`/`psf-memo-indexer` changes. + +No hardening fix was required. The refactorer's property tests already cover the avatar URL +byte limit, UTF-8 round trips, byte-budget conservation, and the over-limit rejection path, +and language mutation reports no survivors in the changed source files. + +## Verification results + +### Language mutation (`mutate4javascript`, differential vs manifest, `--max-workers 8`) +Every changed testable source file is fully killed (0 survivors, 0 uncovered): +- `psf-memo-client/src/services/memo-profile-text-action.js` — 3/3 killed (new base) +- `memo-set-avatar-url.js`, `memo-set-bio.js`, `memo-set-name.js` — 0 sites (thin config + wrappers; their logic lives in the fully-killed `MemoProfileTextAction`/`MemoAction` bases) + +The React components (`app-body/account`, `app-body/set-avatar-url`, `app-body`) are JSX UI +modules the mutation tool cannot parse; per the constitution these environmentally +unsuitable UI modules are excluded from mutation testing, and their testable logic lives +in the services above. + +### DRY (`dry4javascript`) +No duplicate candidates found in `src/services`. + +### CRAP / cyclomatic complexity (`crap4javascript`) +All changed functions within threshold: `profileTextConfig` CC 1, 100% branch coverage, +CRAP 1.0. The three thin action subclasses expose no functions (config-only declarations). + +### Soft Gherkin acceptance mutation (`gherkin-mutator --level soft`) +**psf-memo-client** `set-avatar-url.feature`: 12 executed, **6 killed, 6 survived**. +- Scenario 1 (valid avatar URL broadcast) `m1`,`m2`: mutated capitalization of the URL + example survives because the assertion echoes the broadcast value from the same example + (weak/tautological example-to-assertion connection). Specifier-side feature-quality item. +- Scenario 3 (over-long URL rejected) `m4`,`m5`: mutated chars still leave the URL over the + 217-byte limit, so rejection is unchanged — genuine equivalents. +- Scenario 4 (byte counter) `m9`,`m13`: mutated chars leave the byte length unchanged, so + the remaining count is identical — genuine equivalents. + +The sibling features touched by the shared-base refactor were also re-verified: +`set-bio.feature` (6 killed, 6 survived) and `set-name.feature` (7 killed, 7 survived), all +survivors being the same capitalization/same-length equivalents or tautological-assertion +cases. No implementation changes are warranted; the equivalents are intrinsic and the +tautological-assertion cases are specifier feature-quality improvements. + +## Suite status +- `psf-memo-client`: unit **74 passing**, property **11 passing**, acceptance **pass** + (8 feature files), lint **pass**. + +## Handoffs sent +- No coder/refactorer handoff: the architect made no functional changes requiring follow-up + review (only the durable report and tool-generated mutation manifests). +- No specifier handoff: no specification changes in this commit (the feature-file mutation + manifests are tool-generated metadata; the weak-scenario findings are recorded here for + the specifier in the durable report). + +By architect. diff --git a/psf-memo-client/specs/set-avatar-url.feature b/psf-memo-client/specs/set-avatar-url.feature index b800da2..7a03f92 100644 --- a/psf-memo-client/specs/set-avatar-url.feature +++ b/psf-memo-client/specs/set-avatar-url.feature @@ -1,3 +1,7 @@ +# acceptance-mutation-manifest-begin +# {"version":1,"tested_at":"2026-08-27T16:58:51.862423444Z","feature_name":"Set Avatar URL","feature_path":"/home/trout/work/psf-memo/.worktrees/architect/psf-memo-client/specs/set-avatar-url.feature","background_hash":"e1d5f81f1ed083ac6934c429ca3cb4a0f8d4dac44c2eaa45c0960920bde2c017","implementation_hash":"unknown","scenarios":[{"index":1,"name":"Set Avatar URL - 2 an empty avatar URL is rejected on the set avatar page","scenario_hash":"297768a79c84fa3e7394112d688c046be75a3f9fef80ed784b745e7b637878ee","mutation_count":1,"result":{"Total":1,"Killed":1,"Survived":0,"Errors":0},"tested_at":"2026-08-27T16:58:43.073982780Z"}]} +# acceptance-mutation-manifest-end + # Scenarios: Set Avatar URL - 1, Set Avatar URL - 2, Set Avatar URL - 3, Set Avatar URL - 4, Set Avatar URL - 5 Feature: Set Avatar URL diff --git a/psf-memo-client/specs/set-bio.feature b/psf-memo-client/specs/set-bio.feature index 337bb19..21662db 100644 --- a/psf-memo-client/specs/set-bio.feature +++ b/psf-memo-client/specs/set-bio.feature @@ -1,5 +1,5 @@ # acceptance-mutation-manifest-begin -# {"version":1,"tested_at":"2026-08-27T15:07:16.579432218Z","feature_name":"Set Bio","feature_path":"/home/trout/work/psf-memo/.worktrees/architect/psf-memo-client/specs/set-bio.feature","background_hash":"e1d5f81f1ed083ac6934c429ca3cb4a0f8d4dac44c2eaa45c0960920bde2c017","implementation_hash":"unknown","scenarios":[{"index":1,"name":"Set Bio - 2 an empty bio is rejected on the set bio page","scenario_hash":"13afeec034e9b128e3e2c2c82f392648a11407b917c33c53d13185cc9d8bf2b7","mutation_count":1,"result":{"Total":1,"Killed":1,"Survived":0,"Errors":0},"tested_at":"2026-08-27T15:06:58.731115193Z"}]} +# {"version":1,"tested_at":"2026-08-27T16:58:59.832784881Z","feature_name":"Set Bio","feature_path":"/home/trout/work/psf-memo/.worktrees/architect/psf-memo-client/specs/set-bio.feature","background_hash":"e1d5f81f1ed083ac6934c429ca3cb4a0f8d4dac44c2eaa45c0960920bde2c017","implementation_hash":"unknown","scenarios":[{"index":1,"name":"Set Bio - 2 an empty bio is rejected on the set bio page","scenario_hash":"13afeec034e9b128e3e2c2c82f392648a11407b917c33c53d13185cc9d8bf2b7","mutation_count":1,"result":{"Total":1,"Killed":1,"Survived":0,"Errors":0},"tested_at":"2026-08-27T15:06:58.731115193Z"}]} # acceptance-mutation-manifest-end # Scenarios: Set Bio - 1, Set Bio - 2, Set Bio - 3, Set Bio - 4, Set Bio - 5 diff --git a/psf-memo-client/specs/set-name.feature b/psf-memo-client/specs/set-name.feature index 7ca0982..af575c6 100644 --- a/psf-memo-client/specs/set-name.feature +++ b/psf-memo-client/specs/set-name.feature @@ -1,5 +1,5 @@ # acceptance-mutation-manifest-begin -# {"version":1,"tested_at":"2026-08-26T04:22:57.360768955Z","feature_name":"Set Name","feature_path":"../../specs/set-name.feature","background_hash":"e1d5f81f1ed083ac6934c429ca3cb4a0f8d4dac44c2eaa45c0960920bde2c017","implementation_hash":"unknown","scenarios":[{"index":1,"name":"Set Name - 2 an empty name is rejected on the set name page","scenario_hash":"a4fbf28bd1afbffeff2f24f685299663df57e3cc4332a115fea84c08db634670","mutation_count":1,"result":{"Total":1,"Killed":1,"Survived":0,"Errors":0},"tested_at":"2026-08-26T03:34:50.405131105Z"}]} +# {"version":1,"tested_at":"2026-08-27T16:59:00.404406977Z","feature_name":"Set Name","feature_path":"/home/trout/work/psf-memo/.worktrees/architect/psf-memo-client/specs/set-name.feature","background_hash":"e1d5f81f1ed083ac6934c429ca3cb4a0f8d4dac44c2eaa45c0960920bde2c017","implementation_hash":"unknown","scenarios":[{"index":1,"name":"Set Name - 2 an empty name is rejected on the set name page","scenario_hash":"a4fbf28bd1afbffeff2f24f685299663df57e3cc4332a115fea84c08db634670","mutation_count":1,"result":{"Total":1,"Killed":1,"Survived":0,"Errors":0},"tested_at":"2026-08-27T16:59:00.404406977Z"}]} # acceptance-mutation-manifest-end # Scenarios: Set Name - 1, Set Name - 2, Set Name - 3, Set Name - 4, Set Name - 5 diff --git a/psf-memo-client/src/services/memo-profile-text-action.js b/psf-memo-client/src/services/memo-profile-text-action.js index 9cd9f9e..041d76a 100644 --- a/psf-memo-client/src/services/memo-profile-text-action.js +++ b/psf-memo-client/src/services/memo-profile-text-action.js @@ -52,3 +52,7 @@ class MemoProfileTextAction extends MemoAction { MemoProfileTextAction.profileTextConfig = profileTextConfig module.exports = MemoProfileTextAction + +// mutate4javascript-manifest-begin +// {"version":1,"tested_at":"2026-08-27T16:57:59.182Z","module_hash":"101611ef1fa18260af869f9c65140a4ef35716649a5a0a64e838fe68d5114b4f","functions":[{"id":"func/profileTextConfig","name":"profileTextConfig","line":27,"end_line":40,"hash":"73d0c1953b628958acf23c16ae27f38c200bafc8568cb0daa8737ea2be2282c8"},{"id":"func/MemoProfileTextAction.constructor","name":"MemoProfileTextAction.constructor","line":45,"end_line":49,"hash":"75d5bb04a9d31690f94a3e2337cce03cbe62202bb4fd33b44949562288626605"}]} +// mutate4javascript-manifest-end diff --git a/psf-memo-client/src/services/memo-set-avatar-url.js b/psf-memo-client/src/services/memo-set-avatar-url.js index 519473a..677d7b3 100644 --- a/psf-memo-client/src/services/memo-set-avatar-url.js +++ b/psf-memo-client/src/services/memo-set-avatar-url.js @@ -37,5 +37,5 @@ MemoSetAvatarUrl.MAX_AVATAR_URL_BYTES = MAX_AVATAR_URL_BYTES module.exports = MemoSetAvatarUrl // mutate4javascript-manifest-begin -// {"version":1,"tested_at":"2026-08-27T16:55:55.303Z","module_hash":"473dc38c01f201fb09484ef6288c8ab86ca3457f9e3871cee279c119b65bb44a","functions":[]} +// {"version":1,"tested_at":"2026-08-27T16:58:11.278Z","module_hash":"473dc38c01f201fb09484ef6288c8ab86ca3457f9e3871cee279c119b65bb44a","functions":[]} // mutate4javascript-manifest-end diff --git a/psf-memo-client/src/services/memo-set-bio.js b/psf-memo-client/src/services/memo-set-bio.js index a66ae4e..e37823c 100644 --- a/psf-memo-client/src/services/memo-set-bio.js +++ b/psf-memo-client/src/services/memo-set-bio.js @@ -37,5 +37,5 @@ MemoSetBio.MAX_BIO_BYTES = MAX_BIO_BYTES module.exports = MemoSetBio // mutate4javascript-manifest-begin -// {"version":1,"tested_at":"2026-08-27T16:55:54.606Z","module_hash":"4da70e80defe9ae983bb914d305228497f4877dd43be7f63d6858bf456cf3ab7","functions":[]} +// {"version":1,"tested_at":"2026-08-27T16:58:18.035Z","module_hash":"4da70e80defe9ae983bb914d305228497f4877dd43be7f63d6858bf456cf3ab7","functions":[]} // mutate4javascript-manifest-end diff --git a/psf-memo-client/src/services/memo-set-name.js b/psf-memo-client/src/services/memo-set-name.js index 11c77a8..a417a43 100644 --- a/psf-memo-client/src/services/memo-set-name.js +++ b/psf-memo-client/src/services/memo-set-name.js @@ -37,5 +37,5 @@ MemoSetName.MAX_NAME_BYTES = MAX_NAME_BYTES module.exports = MemoSetName // mutate4javascript-manifest-begin -// {"version":1,"tested_at":"2026-08-27T16:55:54.963Z","module_hash":"4ec10f6de6698eaa32c5fa4c91b8432f910c0dfa2842742aff90ef390a219189","functions":[]} +// {"version":1,"tested_at":"2026-08-27T16:58:25.109Z","module_hash":"4ec10f6de6698eaa32c5fa4c91b8432f910c0dfa2842742aff90ef390a219189","functions":[]} // mutate4javascript-manifest-end