diff --git a/docs/reviews/youtube-embed-summary.md b/docs/reviews/youtube-embed-summary.md index 04c2f94..09da7ea 100644 --- a/docs/reviews/youtube-embed-summary.md +++ b/docs/reviews/youtube-embed-summary.md @@ -48,3 +48,49 @@ ## Handoffs sent - `git_handoff` to coder and refactorer (`priority: 00`) with the review commit for follow-up review. + +--- + +# Follow-up review: property tests (batch 20260904T164750Z) + +**By architect.** + +## Task and commits reviewed +- Follow-up on `youtube-embed`: refactorer added property tests pinning down the parser's + invariants over broad random inputs. +- Inbound handoff: refactorer `9ec8760b59` (merged onto `swarmforge-architect`). +- Reviewed commit: `9ec8760b59` — new `psf-memo-client/test/property/youtube-embed.property.test.js` + (119 lines, 4 properties). No source change. + +## Architectural findings +- **Good test placement:** property tests live in `test/property/`, separate from unit tests, + per the constitution (property tests are not part of normal unit coverage, mutation, CRAP, + or Gherkin mutation). They are run via the dedicated `npm run test:property` command. +- **Sound invariants:** the four properties (round-trip reconstruction, segment shape with + URL-safe video ids, non-YouTube URLs staying text, and video-id round trips) are meaningful + and exercise the parser's URL splitting and trailing-punctuation handling over a token pool + that mixes words, YouTube links, non-YouTube links, and punctuation. +- **Deterministic:** uses the shared seeded `harness.js` PRNG (seed 20260904), so runs are + reproducible. Tests run sequentially under node:test, so the shared rng stream is stable. +- No structural or boundary issues; no changes required. + +## Verification results +- **Property tests** (`npm run test:property`): 37 passing (33 prior + 4 new), 0 fail. +- **Language mutation** (`mutate4javascript src/services/youtube-embed.js --max-workers 8 --mutate-all`): + Killed 6, Survived 1, Uncovered 0. The sole survivor (`line 82 1 -> 0` in `parsePostText`, + `match[1]` → `match[0]`) is the previously documented genuine equivalent (`URL_RE`'s capture + group spans the whole pattern). Property tests are excluded from mutation coverage by design. +- **DRY** (`dry4javascript src/services/youtube-embed.js`): no duplicate candidates. +- **Soft Gherkin acceptance mutation** (`gherkin-mutator --level soft` on `youtube-embed.feature`): + 7 killed, 18 survived. All 18 survivors are single-character case/value mutations of example + values (addresses, txids, text, URLs) used consistently on both the setup and assertion sides + of their scenarios — intrinsic equivalents for a read-only feature, not implementation gaps. +- **Unit tests** (`npm test`): 260 passing, 0 fail. **Lint:** clean. + +## Suite status +- psf-memo-client: 260 unit passing, 37 property passing, lint clean. No source change, so + acceptance behavior is unchanged from the prior review. + +## Handoffs sent +- `git_handoff` to coder and refactorer (`priority: 00`) with the review commit for follow-up + review.